MSC: Suggested improvements and new discovery

. Tuesday, September 6, 2011
  • Agregar a Technorati
  • Agregar a Del.icio.us
  • Agregar a DiggIt!
  • Agregar a Yahoo!
  • Agregar a Google
  • Agregar a Meneame
  • Agregar a Furl
  • Agregar a Reddit
  • Agregar a Magnolia
  • Agregar a Blinklist
  • Agregar a Blogmarks

Received a reply from Dr J yesterday.
Listed below are the suggested improvements and its state:

  1. Use round figures to label the x-axis of your graphs (done)
  2. Show more in-game screenshots of you SNN-driven car – although it is not of much scientific value here but nice pictures always gets attention
  3. Think of plotting the path driven by the best evolved SNNs as they move across the track over the racing period
  4. Avoid saying that your evolved controllers were so easily beaten by human and some of the included controllers.
  5. Also, your explanation that humans cheat by flooring the accelerator is not convincing since if it is allowed in the game, then it is not cheating. What I meant by cheating is when the game AI controllers break rules such as achieving top speed immediately (as opposed to flooring the accelerator but gradual build-up of speed) or in the case of RTS, being able to see through fog-of-war, then that’s cheating. So I recommend that you amend the way you are currently explaining this point.
  6. Please add in a detailed description of your fitness function including a mathematical formula for it. (done)
Discovered something new. In track 1, the controller is able to start by flooring the gas pedal, but it is still slower than the other car because of the gear change strategy. The evolved controller increased gear earlier than the static controller, hence picked up speed slower than it.

Drew track path, but...

Notice that
championship2011server uses a car1-trb1 and the others bot using the same car are:
  • tita 3
  • berniw 3
  • olethros 3
  • lliaw 3
  • inferno 3
  • bt 3

0 comments:

me me